Residential Electricity Consumer Watchlist

by contact on February 10, 2007

Residential Electricity Consumer Watchlist


What to Ask and Watch Out for when Choosing a Residential Electricity Provider   

By Donny Eisenbach

February 10, 2007   

Contact me    

Residential Electricity is usually a mystery as far as what a consumer is actually paying for or even agreeing to before signing a contract. The beginning decision on who to switch to can be such a nightmare many consumers stay on a higher electric rate simply because the information available to determine what to look for when choosing electricity companies is not available. The Texas market happens to be the biggest market in terms of choosing a competitive retail electricity provider. Because of this it’s important to see how they have done things in Texas in order to know what to do in the newly deregulated markets throughout the United States.Illinois has just begun to deregulate their electricity market and there will be millions of residential customers wondering what they should do when deciding on who to switch to. To begin lets take a look at an electric bill. There are three components to an electric bill. There is the “Energy only” portion of the bill. This is the portion of the bill that has become deregulated and is available to be competitively priced. You then have the “Wires charges”, these also go by the name “TDSP charges”, “Transmission and Distribution charges” and “Pass thrus charges”. These charges are regulated by the government and will always be regulated. There will never be more then one electric pole and wire coming to a residential house. The final charges on the bill are the “Taxes”.  

Knowing the three components of the bill helps in determining what questions to ask a Retail Electric Provider who may call on the phone or send a mail advertisement attempting to switch a consumer to their residential electricity product. Usually the Retail Electric Supplier will quote a retail consumer a “energy only” rate that will be low and attractive sounding. The questions a consumer should ask are, “Is this a fixed electric rate or a variable electric rate?” If the provider says it is variable then that means it can change. The rate may be good for the first month but can then increase dramatically on the second month and from then on. The exception to this would be if it was a true follow the market rate that followed the natural gas market. If this were the case then the rate could go up or down based upon what natural gas is doing. The consumer would be taking on this risk and so the rate should be much lower then the standard fixed rate offered by the same electric company. If the fixed rate is not much different then it would be better to stay on a fixed rate or find an alternative electric company.

The next question to ask would be, “Are there any fees that have been taken out of the Retail “Energy only” rate and added in a line item somewhere else in the contract?” Sometimes a Retail Electric Provider will strip out some charges that normally appear in the “energy only” rate and put this in a line item close to the “TDSP charges”. Several providers do this and a consumer should look out for this unethical but legal business practice. So far the Texas PUC has not legally come down against any of the Retail Electric Providers that have done this. We expect that eventually one of the electric companies will be sued and the PUC will rule that this type of clever contract term and agreement clause cannot be done. Until then look out for this. A consumer may think they are signing up on the best electric rate when it may be one of the worst electric rates. Another question to ask is, “What is the early termination fee?” Most electric providers charge a standard penalty that is something like $10 -$15 a month of however many months remain on the electric contract. This would be considered a fair penalty. The reason this would be fair is because the Retail Electric Providers buy this energy out on the open market, hedge it, split it up and then resell it. It is not like a cell phone contract. It’s more like buying a stock and watching it go down and deciding that you want your original investment back. The Electric Provider is of course not going to be willing to let you out of the contract unless rates are even higher then where they were when you got in. The worst case electricity contract early termination penalty that we have seen was with Gexa Energy charging 3 months averaged out bills as the penalty. This of course would be a large sum for a family who most likely is being evicted or moving out of state having to now pay an unreasonable cancellation panelty.

The final question would be to ask if the “TDSP charges” have the energy only charge bundled in with it. Occasionally a provider will quote an electric consumer a bundled rate that includes both the “TDSP charges” and “Energy only” charges. Since an electric consumer cannot do anything about the “TDSP charges” it should not be a consideration when pricing among several electric providers. If this is the case the “Energy only” portion of the rate needs to be determined so the consumer can succesfully compare the rate with other competitive electric rates being offerred.

In summary, be sure to compare residential electricity rates wth multiple electric companies and suppliers before making a decision. Also, most states require the electric provider have an electricity facts label as a step to educate and inform the consumer so they do not buy something they were not properly educated about beforehand. This electricity facts label along with this article will help in educating an energy consumer to make good buying decisions when finally deciding on an electricity company.

Additional Resources   

http://www.icc.illinois.gov/consumer/   

http://www.powertochoose.org/   

http://www.eia.doe.gov/neic/brochure/electricity/electricity.html

is usually a mystery as far as what a consumer is actually paying for or even agreeing to before signing a contract. The beginning decision on who to switch to can be such a nightmare many consumers stay on a higher electric rate simply because the information available to determine what to look for when choosing electricity companies is not available. The Texas market happens to be the biggest market in terms of choosing a competitive retail electricity provider. Because of this it’s important to see how they have done things in Texas in order to know what to do in the newly deregulated markets throughout the United States.Illinois has just begun to deregulate their electricity market and there will be millions of residential customers wondering what they should do when deciding on who to switch to. To begin lets take a look at an electric bill. There are three components to an electric bill. There is the “Energy only” portion of the bill. This is the portion of the bill that has become deregulated and is available to be competitively priced. You then have the “Wires charges”, these also go by the name “TDSP charges”, “Transmission and Distribution charges” and “Pass thrus charges”. These charges are regulated by the government and will always be regulated. There will never be more then one electric pole and wire coming to a residential house. The final charges on the bill are the “Taxes”.  

  is usually a mystery as far as what a consumer is actually paying for or even agreeing to before signing a contract. The beginning decision on who to switch to can be such a nightmare many consumers stay on a higher electric rate simply because the information available to determine what to look for when choosing electricity companies is not available. The Texas market happens to be the biggest market in terms of choosing a competitive retail electricity provider. Because of this it’s important to see how they have done things in Texas in order to know what to do in the newly deregulated markets throughout the United States.Illinois has just begun to deregulate their electricity market and there will be millions of residential customers wondering what they should do when deciding on who to switch to. To begin lets take a look at an electric bill. There are three components to an electric bill. There is the “Energy only” portion of the bill. This is the portion of the bill that has become deregulated and is available to be competitively priced. You then have the “Wires charges”, these also go by the name “TDSP charges”, “Transmission and Distribution charges” and “Pass thrus charges”. These charges are regulated by the government and will always be regulated. There will never be more then one electric pole and wire coming to a residential house. The final charges on the bill are the “Taxes”.  

[?]
Share This

{ 1 comment }

Residential Rates are back down to the 10 cent per KWh range.
Consumer Strategist
 


Texas Electric Company Reporting – Donny Eisenbach
 

10 – 10.8 cent per KWh electricity rates are showing back up in Texas but are these rates legit?
January marks the beginning for a month with no marked price-to-beat rate.  This means incumbent electric providers can charge whatever they want. A few of

the electric retail providers pricing electric energy rates at around 10 cents per kilowatt-hour to 10.8 cents. Reliant Energy still offers a 16 cent per KWh

residential rate even though rates have dramatically climbed down. This would be price gauging by most peoples estimation. What type of people do they charge

this rate to?  Someone is buying but exactly who and how did they get you?
 

The public utility commission estimates about 30% of North Texas have switched from TXU to another Retail Electric Company.
 

Now that the price-to-beat is no longer active is it a good time to switch retail electric providers?
 

There are these low electric rates being offerred on a month-to-month basis but these plans are strictly market rates so when natural gas rates go up so does

your rate.  The spikes that occur with natural gas can sometimes be 3 times higher then a previous month.  Is this really a smart choice for Residential

customers who don’t know any better? Startex Power, Reliant Energy, Commerce Energy, and Amigo Energy currently have these market plans available and they

are good so long as you know what you are getting into.
 

When the natural gas spot rate goes up on the NYMEX and Henry Hub expect the same to happen to electricity rates. Natural Gas and coal makes up about 75% of

the electricity cost of generation.  Expect to see consumers feeling as if they were tricked into something they weren’t educated on.
 

While Natural gas continues to fall lower this does represent an opportunity to educated consumers who are willing to take on the risk of gas spikes. If a

consumer is concerned about an unexpected rate hike because of the commodity market in Natural Gas rising higher from anything from a hurricane to a mideast

war issue then stay away.
 

No one wants a higher electric bill but this is what happens when taking on your own risk instead of letting the electric company hedge the electric energy

and offer a fixed rate. Customers make the decision so long as they are informed about the rate, otherwise they get into a low rate they know nothing about.

Reliant Energy is a large enough experienced company to lead the way in providing a truly understandable natural gas electric plan that anyone can

understand.  We hope they choose to do this.
 

Commerce energy is aggressively seeking new customers and have a 10 cent market rate that is competitive when put side-by-side the other Retail Electric

Providers.
 

Reliant energy, has a new PowerTracker plan that starts at 10.3 cents.
 

Reliant Energy’s rate is based on a Natural Gas formula using the NYMEX natural gas futures’ contract price and a market conditions multiplier that is

supposed to reflect market changes.
 

As with any electric rate the rate also has some built in fees related to the customer’s electric utility TDSP service area.
 

It is veyr important for consumers to stay informed because this plan is absolutely not for everyone and could easily be cause for some irate non paying

customers if Natural Gas Prices spke up.
 

With a residence you usually pay at the most $500 a month so if the electric rate spikes the Retail Electric Providers assume you will be able to pay the

bill still if the average month bill increases to say $1000.  At this time a consumer who was unhappy could convert to a fixed price to avoid any future rate

spikes.
 

Because these plans have no long term commitment you can convert to fixed price at any time.
 

The big companies have coined the term “market-tracker” as the type of product that follows the Natural Gas futures market on the NYMEX exchange. The

market-tracker plan follows natural-gas prices. TXU’s plan is a 24-month contract with a $200 cancellation fee at 15 cents a killowatt hour right. This rate

is extraordinarily high and the people locking into this rate are being gouged severily.
The positive aspect of this plan is that it caps its rate and provides protection from short-term spikes. The negative to this plan is that it does so at a

premium that makes no sense for being so high.
 

Now that the “price to beat” rate is finished because of the government deregulation process, we will see continued lower rates in the form of market rates

for energy and fixed electric rates.
 

Gas prices were as high as $12 after Hurricanes Katrina and Rita but since this time the natural gas spot price has dropped enough to allow for truly

discounted rates at around 10 cents per KWh.
Natural gas prices are purely a guessing game and are highly speculated as to what they will do next.  As of Feb 2007 they are currently quite a nit above

the averages from lat year at this time.  This is due largely to colder then expected weather.  This week in Texas the weather is warming up again and

natural gas prices will likely drop the week of Feb 4 2007.
 

Because of the volatility, the lack of a minimum term may help consumers, he said.
 

“If prices get to the point beyond their tolerance level, they could leave the rate,” he said.
 

At this time the deregulated electricity market has not seen the low rates promised by the Texas deregulation plan but the more interest energy consumers

show in a true energy market rate the lower the rates will go.
 

The best residential electric contract option at this time in the market would be a 10 cent fixed priced product for residential customers.  Right now the

demand is just not there for electric companies to go there.
 

Here are a few Retail Electricity Companies offering Market Rate prices following the natural gas market.
 

10.3 cents
 

Reliant Energy,
 

866-222-7100,
 

www.reliantenergy.com. Plan becomes available Monday.
 

10.4 cents
 

Commerce Energy, Costa Mesa, Calif.: 877-226-5425, www.commerceenergy.com. Includes $4.95 monthly service charge.
 

10.8 cents
 

StarTex Power,
 

866-917-8271,
 

www.startexpower.com.
 

10.8 cents
 

Amigo Energy,
 

888-469-2644,
 

www.amigoenergy.com. $6.95 charge for using less than 500 kWh.
 

SOURCES: Reliant Energy,
 

Commerce Energy, StarTex Power, Amigo Energy
 

FOR MORE INFORMATION
 

Natural-gas prices can be followed on www.naturalgasprice.net
 

[?]
Share This

{ 10 comments }

People are climbing electric poles and stealing electricity in Houston

February 3, 2007

In the Houston area their are people who are stealing electricity by directly connecting power plates and extension cords on power lines.  These people actually climb the poles and hook their cables directly into the power line trying not to get electrified in the process.  Are energy rates really getting so high that people are resorting to risking [...]

Read the full article →

What happens when my electric company goes bankrupt?

February 3, 2007

TXU for instance would be your “POLR” For those of you who wonder what happens when an electric company goes bankrupt and your concerned about losing service, here is an article to alleviate this fear. Safety-net Electric Rates Fall in Houston area PUC, TXU Agree on new “Provider of Last Resort” Terms Contact: Terry Hadley [...]

Read the full article →

Electricity Facts among the deregulated states

February 3, 2007

What are the real facts concerning a possible failed energy deregulation process in the United States? Facts among each deregulated state in the United States vary. Because the facts vary it is important to read them all and find the inconsistencies and make sense of it all. The question is: Does Electricity Deregulation help a state [...]

Read the full article →

Natural Gas Company List, Distribution, Transportation, and purchasers

February 1, 2007

Crude Oil and Natural Gas Purchasers Company List: Amerada Hess American Refining Amoco Arco Atlantic Richfield Ashland Basis Petroleum BCO Big Heart Big West BP Calumet Cardinal Cenex Champlin Charter Chevron ChevronTexaco Citgo Citronelle Coastal Derby Coastal States Coffeville Conoco ConocoPhillips Conoco NGL CountryMark CRA Crown Central Diamond Shamrock Douglas Duke NGL Dynegy El Paso [...]

Read the full article →

Natural Gas Company List, Distribution, Transportation, and purchasers

February 1, 2007

Crude Oil and Natural Gas Purchasers Company List: Amerada Hess American Refining Amoco Arco Atlantic Richfield Ashland Basis Petroleum BCO Big Heart Big West BP Calumet Cardinal Cenex Champlin Charter Chevron ChevronTexaco Citgo Citronelle Coastal Derby Coastal States Coffeville Conoco ConocoPhillips Conoco NGL CountryMark CRA Crown Central Diamond Shamrock Douglas Duke NGL Dynegy El Paso [...]

Read the full article →

Centerpoint energy shares fall 1.2 % due to backing out of Natural Gas Pipeline project.

February 1, 2007

Joint venture cancels plans to build natural gas pipeline CenterPoint, Spectra don’t draw enough customers to start project By TOM FOWLER Copyright 2007 Houston Chronicle TOOLS Email Get section feed Print Subscribe NOW [?] Share This

Read the full article →

TXU Energy restarts the 750 megawatt power plant after fixing a tube leak.

February 1, 2007

I know this article about TXU’s power plant sounds unsafe and definitely unclean to both the environment and people but you have to ask yourself, how are you benefiting from the Texas power grid up to this point.  Everyone had to start with coal and natural gas at some point.  They are now working on [...]

Read the full article →

Choosing an Electricity Company such as Spark Energy

February 1, 2007

Competitive Providers Are Pricing But It Is Sometimes Confusing Spark Energy serves Residential and Commercial Customers in Texas and have recently been pricing very competitively.  Deregulation in Texas has begun to show some positive affects for Residential customers as the rates have dropped about 1 penny per KWh over the standard highs. With deregulation coming [...]

Read the full article →